Tragedy, Recognition, and the Death of God Studies in Hegel and Nietzsche

by Williams, Robert R.

• ISBN13: 9780199656059
• ISBN10: 0199656053
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2012-12-12
• Publisher: Oxford University Press

Summary

Hegel and Nietzsche are two of the most important figures in philosophy and religion. Robert R. Williams challenges the view that they are mutually exclusive. He identifies four areas of convergence. First, Hegel and Nietzsche express and define modern interest in tragedy as a philosophical topic. Each seeks to correct the traditional philosophical and theological suppression of a tragic view of existence. This suppression of the tragic is required by the moral vision of the world,both in the tradition and in Kant's practical philosophy and its postulates. For both Hegel and Nietzsche, the moral vision of the world is a projection of spurious, life-negating values that Nietzsche calls the ascetic ideal, and that Hegel identifies as the spurious infinite. The moral God is theenforcer of morality. Second, while acknowledging a tragic dimension of existence, Hegel and Nietzsche nevertheless affirm that existence is good in spite of suffering. Both affirm a vision of human freedom as open to otherness and requiring recognition and community. Struggle and contestation have affirmative significance for both. Third, while the moral God is dead, this does not put an end to the God-question. Theology must incorporate the death of God as its own theme. The union of God anddeath expressing divine love is for Hegel the basic speculative intuition. This implies a dipolar, panentheistic concept of a tragic, suffering God, who risks, loves, and reconciles. Fourth, Williams argues that both Hegel and Nietzsche pursue theodicy, not as a justification of the moral God, butrather as a question of the meaningfulness and goodness of existence despite nihilism and despite tragic conflict and suffering. The inseparability of divine love and anguish means that reconciliation is no conflict-free harmony, but includes a paradoxical tragic dissonance: reconciliation is a disquieted bliss in disaster.

Author Biography

Robert R. Williams is Professor Emeritus of Germanic Studies, Philosophy, and Religious Studies at the University of Illinois at Chicago. He is Past President of the Hegel Society of America (1998-2000), and author of Schleiermacher the Theologian (1978), Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other (1992), Hegel's Ethics of Recognition (1998). He is also editor of Beyond Liberalism and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel's Philosophy of Right (2001), translator (with Claude Welch) of I. A. Dorner's Divine Immutability: A Reconsideration (1994), and translator and editor of Hegel's Lectures on the Philosophy of Spirit, 1827-8 (2007).

Table of Contents

Introduction
Part I: Recognition
1. Hegel and Nietzsche on Master and Slave
2. Aristotle, Hegel, and Nietzsche on Friendship
3. The Agon, Recognition, and Community
Part II: Tragedy
4. Hegel's Conception of Tragedy
5. Nietzsche on Tragedy
Part III: Overcoming the Kantian Frame: The True Infinite
6. Hegel's Concept of the True Infinite
7. Hegel's Recasting of Theological Proofs
Part IV: God beyond the Death of God
8. Theogenesis, Divine Suffering, Demythologizing the Demonic
9. Nietzsche on the Death of God and Eternal Recurrence
10. Hegel on the Death of God: the Inseparability of Love and Anguish
11. Nietzsche's Aesthetic Theodicy
12. Hegel's Death of God Theodicy