Human Rights in the UK Supreme Court

by Dickson, Brice

• ISBN13: 9780199697458
• ISBN10: 0199697450
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2013-05-19
• Publisher: Oxford University Press

Summary

How does the UK Supreme Court approach human rights law? This book presents the first comprehensive overview of the human rights jurisprudence of the Court, analysing the opinions expressed by the current Justices and their predecessors, both judicially and extra-judicially. It criticizes the judges for not developing the common law in a way which supplements the Human Rights Act, for not making imaginative enough use of that Act, and for adopting an attitude to Convention rights which is often out of step with the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. After setting the scene by explaining the constraints which are placed on the Supreme Court Justices, the book considers how human rights are conceptualized by the Court in general and how in particular the procedural questions thrown up by the Human Rights Act have been dealt with so far. It then examines on a right-by-right basis the Justices' position on all the Convention rights and those additional international human rights standards which have been incorporated into UK law. Focusing on the views expressed by individual judges, the book details the many differences of opinion which have come to light and characterizes the prevailing positions, before attempting to predict what stance may be adopted in future on new issues. The book offers an invaluable resource for any practitioners bringing human rights cases before the Court, and its critical arguments on the state of UK human rights law will be essential reading for all academics working in European human rights law.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. The Supreme Court and its Conception of Human Rights
3. Approaches to the Human Rights Act
4. The Right to Life
5. The Right not to be Ill-Treated
6. The Right to Liberty
7. The Right to a Fair Trial
8. The Right to a Private and Family Life
9. The Rights to Believe, Associate, and Marry
10. The Right to Free Speech
11. Equality and Freedom from Discrimination
12. The Right to Property
13. Other Human Rights
14. Conclusion
Appendices
1. Appointments to the Supreme Court
2. Biographies of Supreme Court Justices
3. Decisions by the House of Lords or Supreme Court considered by the European Court of Human Rights
Bibliography