The Plain and Noble Garb of Truth: Nationalism and Impartiality in American Historical Writing, 1784-1860

by Cheng, Eileen Ka-may

• ISBN13: 9780820330730
• ISBN10: 0820330736
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2008-08-15
• Publisher: Univ of Georgia Pr

Summary

American historians of the early national period, argues Eileen Ka-May Cheng, grappled with objectivity, professionalism, and other "modern" issues to a greater degree than their successors in later generations acknowledge. Her extensive readings of antebellum historians show that by the 1820s, a small but influential group of practitioners had begun to develop many of the doctrines and concerns that undergird contemporary historical practice.The Plain and Noble Garb of Truthchallenges the entrenched notion that America's first generations of historians were romantics or propagandists for a struggling young nation.Cheng engages with the works of well-known early national historians like George Bancroft, William Prescott, and David Ramsay; such lesser-known figures as Jared Sparks and Lorenzo Sabine; and leading political and intellectual elites of the day, including Francis Bowen and Charles Francis Adams. She shows that their work, which focused on the American Revolution, was often nuanced and surprisingly sympathetic in its treatment of American Indians and loyalists. She also demonstrates how the rise of the novel contributed to the emergence of history as an autonomous discipline, arguing that paradoxically "early national historians at once described truth in opposition to the novel and were influenced by the novel in their understanding of truth."Modern historians should recognize that the discipline of history is itself a product of history, says Cheng. By taking seriously a group of too-often-dismissed historians, she challenges contemporary historians to examine some ahistorical aspects of the way they understand their own discipline.

Author Biography

Eileen Ka-May Cheng teaches history at Sarah Lawrence College.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments	p. vii
Introduction	p. 1
"To become a historian": A Discipline and a Society in Transition	p. 13
"Histories in Novels," "Novels in Histories": Imagination, Fact, and the Moral Truths of History	p. 52
"To express old things in a new way": Originality and Impartiality in American Historical Methodology	p. 104
Puritanism, Slavery, and the American Revolution: American Exceptionalism and Impartiality	p. 153
The "Losers" of the Revolution: Loyalists, Indians, and the Ideal of Impartiality	p. 208
Conclusion	p. 255
Notes	p. 263
Bibliography	p. 329
Index	p. 359
Table of Contents provided by Ingram. All Rights Reserved.