Education Between State, Markets, and Civil Society: Comparative Perspectives

by Meyer, Heinz-Dieter; Boyd, William Lowe; Boyd, William Lowe; Meyer, Heinz-Dieter

• ISBN13: 9780805831955
• ISBN10: 0805831959
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2001-05-01
• Publisher: Lawrence Erlbau

Summary

*How should education be organized in pluralistic and multicultural societies? *What are the roles in education of civil society, markets, governments, and the family? *How can the idea of the civil society help to reorient education policy discussions that are sometimes stuck in either-or juxtapositions of "market versus government" or "individualism versus communitarianism?" *What are some of the traditions of civil society--across countries and across history--that educators and policymakers today can revive or build on? These questions are at the center of this book. Its goal is to understand how we can accommodate cultural, ethnic, and religious pluralism in a political and conceptual framework that is sufficiently flexible to combine choice with equity, a commitment to a shared civil and political culture with openness to exploring and affirming the distinct ethnicity, race, creed, or culture of different groups. To address these questions, the authors take up the notion of thecivil society,an idea that has experienced a popular and scholarly revival in recent years as numerous citizens, action groups, political philosophers, and social scientists make the case that only a democratic civil society can sustain a democratic state. The implications of this development for education have to date been very little explored. This book is a step toward addressing this gap. Going beyond simple juxtapositions of "market versus government" in education reform, the book as a whole develops an integrative perspective informed by the idea of the civil society. It combines current policy issues with a look at their historical development, and evaluates U.S. educational policy in the context of a range of international cases. The authors--education scholars, sociologists, economists, historians, and philosophers-- explore from diverse disciplinary, political, and philosophical points of view, the potential of the civil society and civic associations for education. At the same time, they share the hope that a thorough reconsideration of the role of the state, the market, and the civil society will help to energize ongoing experiments with charter schools, voucher schemes, and a variety of other plans to increase educational and school autonomy.

Table of Contents

Preface	vii
Civil Society, Pluralism, and Education-Introduction and Overview	1	(12)
Heinz-Dieter Meyer
William Lowe Boyd
Civil Society and Education-The Return of an Idea	13	(22)
Heinz-Dieter Meyer
Civil Society and Schooling: Particularistic Voices and Public Spaces	35	(18)
Kenneth A. Strike
The Idea of an Education Mix: A Proposal to Strengthen Civil Society and Education in Germany	53	(10)
Ingo Richter
Church, State, and Civil Society: The Netherland's System of Schooling	63	(18)
AnneBert Dijkstra
Jaap Dronkers
The State and Civil Society in Education in England: Past Developments and Current Problems	81	(20)
Geoffrey Walford
Schools Between State and Civil Society in Germany and the United States: A Historical Perspective	101	(18)
Jurgen Herbst
Educational Autonomy in a Civil Society: A Model of Checks and Balances	119	(18)
Heinz-Dieter Meyer
Vouchers: Still (Largely) Untested and Why	137	(24)
Bruce S. Cooper
E. Vance Randall
Expanding the Third Sector in Education? A Critical View	161	(16)
Manfred Weiss
School Voluntarism, Social Capital, and Civil Society	177	(20)
Daniel J. Brown
Balancing the State, Markets, and Civil Society in Education Reform: Trends and Issues in England and the United States	197	(26)
William Lowe Boyd
Beyond the Nation-State: Educational Contention in Global Civil Society	223	(20)
Karen Mundy
Lynn Murphy
Contributors	243	(2)
Index	245