From Placebo to Panacea Putting Psychiatric Drugs to the Test

by Fisher, Seymour; Greenberg, Roger P.

• ISBN13: 9780471148487
• ISBN10: 0471148482
• Edition: 1st
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 1997-10-07
• Publisher: Wiley

Summary

FROM PLACEBO TO PANACEA With the latest generation of psychoactive drugs, has pharmacology at last triumphed over mental illness? A close look at world scientific literature would suggest otherwise. The sobering truth is that many claims about the efficacy of drug therapies for everything from depression to schizophrenia have been exaggerated. What, then, accounts for the inflated confidence clinicians and the lay public alike often have in the new generation of "wonder drugs"? Find out in From Placebo to Panacea. From Placebo to Panacea is not an indictment of drug therapy. Rather, it is a reasoned analysis of the efficacy of psychoactive drugs as compared to other forms of treatment--backed by hard empirical data. Above all, it is meant to function as a therapist's and patient's guide to making more informed decisions when considering treatment options. The book begins with an in-depth discussion of salient problems with standard methods of measuring the usefulness of psychoactive drugs. Next is an exploration of a wide range of factors that can bias test results, both technical (e.g., patients participating in double-blind trials can usually tell whether they are receiving an inactive placebo or a psychoactive drug) and psychosocial. Also considered are problems arising from current systems for diagnosing mental disorders, including complications resulting from comorbidity. Subsequent chapters focus on drug therapies for specific disorders in both adults and children. The authors cover depression and bipolar disorders, schizophrenia, anxiety disorders, borderline personality disorder, attention deficit, and hyperactivity. Each chapter carefully considers the published findings on the disorder under discussion, as well as questions of side effects, suicide, and potential long-term benefits. A final chapter synthesizes the findings from previous chapters into a comprehensive picture of the current state of psychoactive drug therapy. Throughout, the book provides valuable suggestions for ways of improving and building upon existing knowledge. Offering an empirically based appraisal of the strengths and limitations of drug-based treatment for psychiatric disorders, From Placebo to Panacea is must reading for psychiatrists, psychologists, and other mental health professionals, as well as psychopharmacologists and drug development researchers and patients. "The long list of treatment failures, ranging from insulin coma to lobotomy, speaks for itself . . . skepticism should prevail with respect to all evaluations of research, particularly if they involve the welfare of large numbers of persons."--Seymour Fisher and Roger P. Greenberg Is the new generation of psychoactive "wonder drugs" really as effective as it is purported to be? And, perhaps most significant, in an age of managed care, what are the dangers of uncritical faith in the usefulness of these drugs? From Placebo to Panacea examines these questions. It separates fact from fiction, and injects a note of healthy questioning into the otherwise unreserved chorus of praise for psychotropics. From Placebo to Panacea: * Examines the clinical research into outcomes of common drug therapies for most major mental disorders in adults and children Offers analyses of the effectiveness of most common psychotropics in both controlled trials and clinical settings * Explores technical and psychosocial factors that frequently bias test results in favor of drug therapies * Provides critical, empirically based appraisal of the strengths and limitations of drug-based treatment for psychiatric disorders * Compares the relative effectiveness of drug therapy versus nondrug therapies and placebos

Author Biography

SEYMOUR FISHER, PhD, was, until his death in 1996, Professor in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the State University of New York Health Science Center in Syracuse. Dr. Fisher received his doctorate in clinical psychology from the University of Chicago. His previous books include Development and Structure of the Body Image, Sexual Images of the Self, The Psychology of Adaptation to Absurdity, and (with Roger P. Greenberg) Freud Scientifically Reappraised (Wiley). ROGER P. GREENBERG, PhD, is Professor and Head of the Division of Clinical Psychology in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the State University of New York Health Science Center, Syracuse. He also has an active private practice in clinical psychology. He is the author of more than 125 published articles and books, including The Scientific Credibility of Freud's Theories and Therapy (with Seymour Fisher), which, upon its publication, was selected by both the National Library Association and Psychology Today as one of the best books in the behavioral sciences.

Table of Contents

PART ONE CONCEPTUAL ISSUES	3	(112)
1 The Curse of the Placebo: Fanciful Pursuit of a Pure Biological Therapy	3	(54)
Seymour Fisher
Roger P. Greenberg
2 Treatment Implications of Psychiatric Comorbidity	57	(41)
Michael D. Greenberg
3 Costly Compromises: A Critique of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders	98	(17)
Robert C. Carson
PART TWO EFFICACIES OF PSYCHOACTIVE DRUGS FOR ADULTS	115	(192)
4 Mood-Mending Medicines: Probing Drug, Psychotherapy, and Placebo Solutions	115	(58)
Roger P. Greenberg
Seymour Fisher
5 A Critique of the Use of Neuroleptic Drugs in Psychiatry	173	(56)
David Cohen
6 A Focused Empirical Analysis of Treatments for Panic and Anxiety	229	(52)
William G. Danton
David O. Antonuccio
7 Pharmacological Treatments for Borderline Personality Disorder: A Critical Review of the Empirical Literature	281	(26)
Robert F. Bornstein
PART THREE EFFICACIES OF PSYCHOACTIVE DRUGS FOR CHILDREN	307	(52)
8 Are We Justified in Treating Children with Psychotropic Drugs?	307	(16)
Rhoda L. Fisher
Seymour Fisher
9 Stimulant Pharmacotherapy for Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorders: An Analysis of Progress, Problems, and Prospects	323	(36)
Carol K. Whalen
Barbara Henker
PART FOUR OVERVIEW	359	(26)
10 What Are We to Conclude about Psychoactive Drugs? Scanning the Major Findings	359	(26)
Seymour Fisher
Roger P. Greenberg
Author Index	385	(13)
Subject Index	398