Strategic Planning in Environmental Regulation : A Policy Approach That Works

by Cohen, Steven; Kamieniecki, Sheldon; Cahn, Matthew Alan

• ISBN13: 9780262033411
• ISBN10: 0262033410
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2005-12-01
• Publisher: Mit Pr

Summary

Strategic Planning in Environmental Regulationintroduces an approach to environmental regulatory planning founded on a creative, interactive relationship between business and government. The authors argue that regulation-often too narrowly defined as direct, command-and-control standard-setting and enforcement-should include the full range of activities intended to influence private behavior to conform to public goals. The concept of strategic regulatory planning that the book introduces provides a model for designing more effective environmental regulation. Strategic planning requires careful consideration of the regulatory objectives, the target audiences for regulation, and the characteristics of the regulatory agency. The two important case studies in the book-one on the use of the gasoline additive MTBE and the other on the cleanup of underground storage tanks (USTs)-apply the model, compare the approaches and results, and illustrate the advantages of a strategic approach. The case of MTBE-in which an additive intended to produce cleaner-burning gasoline was found to contribute to both air and groundwater pollution-shows the drawbacks of top-down regulation by fragmented regulatory agencies. The success of the UST cleanup, in contrast, highlights a unique, strategic, and results-oriented approach to policy implementation. These two cases demonstrate why regulation works better in some cases than others, and the alternative approaches to regulation described in the book promise to promote the achievement of environmental quality goals.

Table of Contents

Series Foreword	ix
Preface	xiii
Acknowledgments	xvii
Introduction	1	(18)
I Strategic Planning and Effective Regulation	19	(80)
1 The Problem of Regulatory Strategy Formulation	21	(22)
2 A Strategic Approach to the Regulatory Planning Process	43	(20)
3 A Conceptual Framework for Selecting Regulatory Devices	63	(16)
4 A Menu of Regulatory Devices	79	(20)
II Regulation without Strategy: The Case of Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether	99	(54)
5 MTBE and Clean Air Regulation	101	(16)
6 Failure in Regulatory Planning	117	(18)
7 A Strategic Approach to MTBE Regulation	135	(18)
III Regulation with Strategy: The Case of Underground Storage Tanks	153	(70)
8 The Problem of Leaking Underground Storage Tanks	155	(22)
9 A Strategic Regulatory Plan for Underground Storage Tanks	177	(16)
10 Ex Post Review and Revision: Eighteen Years Later	193	(30)
Conclusion	223	(22)
Notes	245	(40)
Bibliography	285	(22)
Index	307