Afghanistan As a Federal System With Autonomous Regions

It is debatable whether Afghanistan historically meets most accepted definitions of a nation state. Afghanistan has historically been governed by local and tribal leaders with short-lived attempts at a strong central unitary government. Whenever there has been a strong central government, it has relatively quickly been removed from power. The people of Afghanistan resent strong central government and demonstrate this through their repeated revolts and coups that follow any bold government intrusion in their lives. King Amanullah's sweeping attempts at westernization of the country and the subsequent coup that overthrew him demonstrates this. This historical trend raises questions about the United States' current efforts to strengthen Afghanistan's central government. Given the current United States administration's goal to reevaluate Afghan policy, this research subject is timely. This monograph asserts that Afghanistan should be governed utilizing a federal system with strong autonomous areas. It begins with a discussion of the modern history of Afghanistan, focusing on governance, and a brief background of Afghan cultural demographics. The second segment defines a federal system and an autonomous region. It also shows the strengths and weaknesses of each form of government. The third segment will be a case study of the countries of Spain, Belgium, and the autonomous region of Kurdistan in Iraq. Both Spain and Belgium are examples of nation-states that are made-up of strong ethnic groups in which a federal system with autonomous regions has helped to stabilize. The region of Kurdistan within Iraq is an example of a country using an autonomous region to decrease ethnic violence and separatist movements with a positive outcome. The analysis of these three case studies will focus first upon the strengths exhibited by these chosen political systems. The second part of the analysis will demonstrate the current parallels between these federal systems of government and autonomous regions and the situation in Afghanistan. The third portion of the analysis will explore the current challenges within Afghanistan that could be alleviated utilizing this alternative political system. Finally, this analysis will lead to a conclusion and recommendation that Afghanistan should alter its government's current design and adopt a federal system with strong autonomous regions. The monograph will not examine how to execute possible autonomous regions within Afghanistan and how the federal system should be specifically structured. This is a topic for future research.