Setting Limits Fairly Can We Learn to Share Medical Resources?

by Daniels, Norman; Sabin, James

• ISBN13: 9780195149364
• ISBN10: 019514936X
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 2002-02-14
• Publisher: Oxford University Press

Summary

The central idea for this book is that we lack consensus on principles for allocating resources and in the absence of such a consensus we must rely on a fair decision-making process for setting limits on health care. The authors characterize key elements of this process in a variety of health care contexts where such decisions are made- decisions about insurance coverage for new technologies, pharmacy benefit management, the design of physician incentives, contracting for mental health care by public agencies, etc.- and they connect the problem in the U.S. with the same problem in other countries. They provide a cogent analysis of the current situation, lucidly review the usual candidate solutions, and describe their own approach, which represents a clear advance in thinking. Their intended audience is international since the problem of limits cuts across types of health care systems whether or not they have universal coverage.

Author Biography

James E. Sabin is a Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at Harvard Medical School, Director of the Ethics Program at Harvard Pilgrim Health Care and Co-Director of the Center for Ethics in Managed Care.

Table of Contents

Our Lives in Whose Hands?	1	(12)
Justice, Scarcity, and Public Accountability for Limits	13	(12)
The Legitimacy Problem and Fair Process	25	(18)
Accountability for Reasonableness	43	(24)
Managing Last-Chance Therapies	67	(18)
Lung Volume Reduction Surgery: A Case Study	85	(20)
Making Pharmacy Benefits Accountable for Reasonableness	105	(16)
Indirect Limit Setting: Accountability for Physician Incentives	121	(14)
Accountability for Reasonableness in Action: Public Sector Mental Health Contracting	135	(14)
An International Learning Curve	149	(20)
Learning to Share Medical Resources	169	(6)
References	175	(8)
Index	183