rent-now

Rent More, Save More! Use code: ECRENTAL

5% off 1 book, 7% off 2 books, 10% off 3+ books

9780072430929

Taking Sides : Clashing Views on Controversial Issues in Health and Society

by ;
  • ISBN13:

    9780072430929

  • ISBN10:

    0072430923

  • Edition: 5th
  • Format: Paperback
  • Copyright: 2001-01-10
  • Publisher: MCG
  • View Upgraded Edition

Note: Supplemental materials are not guaranteed with Rental or Used book purchases.

Purchase Benefits

  • Free Shipping Icon Free Shipping On Orders Over $35!
    Your order must be $35 or more to qualify for free economy shipping. Bulk sales, PO's, Marketplace items, eBooks and apparel do not qualify for this offer.
  • eCampus.com Logo Get Rewarded for Ordering Your Textbooks! Enroll Now
List Price: $27.50 Save up to $6.87
  • Buy Used
    $20.63

    USUALLY SHIPS IN 2-4 BUSINESS DAYS

Summary

This debate-style reader is designed to introduce students to controversies in health science and personal health. The debates are focused around issues of substance use and abuse; sexuality and gender; environment and health; the mind/body relationship and consumer health and nutrition. The student Web site, Dushkin Online (www.dushkin.com/online/), provides study support and links to health-related sites.

Table of Contents

PART 1. The Health Care Industry

ISSUE 1. Will Managed Care Improve Health Care in the United States?

YES: David Jacobsen, from "Cost-Conscious Care", Reason

NO: Ronald J. Glasser, from "The Doctor Is Not In: On the Managed Failure of Managed Health Care", Harper's Magazine

Surgeon David Jacobsen states that health maintenance organizations (HMOs) offer quality care and that high-quality medical care at an affordable price is not only possible under managed care; it is a reality. Pediatrician and author Ronald J. Glasser argues that managed care companies care more for profits than for people.

ISSUE 2. Should Health Care for the Elderly Be Limited?

YES: Daniel Callahan, from "Setting Limits: A Response", The Gerontologist

NO: Patricia Lanoie Blanchette, from "Age-Based Rationing of Healthcare", Generations

Hastings Center director Daniel Callahan contends that medical care for elderly people who have lived their natural life expectancy should consist only of pain relief rather than expensive health care services that serve only to forestall death. Patricia Lanoie Blanchette, a physician and a professor of medicine and public health, argues that health care should not be rationed by age and that age bias should be recognized and confronted.

ISSUE 3. Should Doctors-in-Training Be Unionized?

YES: Andrew C. Yacht, from "Collective Bargaining Is the Right Step", The New England Journal of Medicine

NO: Jordan J. Cohen, from "White Coats Should Not Have Union Labels", The New England Journal of Medicine

Physician Andrew C. Yacht argues that doctors-in-training, like other workers, should have the right to organize and to bargain collectively for better working conditions in hospitals so that they can provide enhanced care for their patients. Physician and medical educator Jordan J. Cohen asserts that doctors-in-training are primarily students, not employees, and that union activities would negatively affect the educational experience.

ISSUE 4. Should Health Insurance Be Based on Employment?

YES: William S. Custer, Charles N. Kahn III, and Thomas F. Wildsmith IV, from "Why We Should Keep the Employment-Based Health Insurance System", Health Affairs

NO: Uwe E. Reinhardt, from "Employer-Based Health Insurance: A Balance Sheet", Health Affairs

Insurance and policy analysts William S. Custer, Charles N. Kahn III, and Thomas F. Wildsmith IV assert that the employment-based health care system in the United States offers a solid, proven foundation on which to base any reform, and that attempts to break the link between employment and health insurance coverage may greatly increase the number of uninsured Americans. Economist Uwe E. Reinhardt argues that, on balance, the debits of the employer-based health insurance system outweigh the credits, and that a parallel system detached from the workplace could eventually absorb the current system.

PART 2. Health and Society

ISSUE 5. Should Doctors Ever Help Terminally Ill Patients to Commit Suicide?

YES: Marcia Angell, from "The Supreme Court and Physician-Assisted Suicide: The Ultimate Right", The New England Journal of Medicine

NO: Kathleen M. Foley, from "Competent Care for the Dying Instead of Physician-Assisted Suicide", The New England Journal of Medicine

Marcia Angell, executive editor of The New England Journal of Medicine, asserts that physician-assisted suicide should be permitted under some circumstances and that not all of the pain of the dying can be controlled. Physician Kathleen M. Foley argues that doctors do not know enough about their patients, themselves, or suffering to provide assistance with dying as a medical treatment for the relief of suffering.

ISSUE 6. Should Human Cloning Ever Be Permitted?

YES: John A. Robertson, from "Human Cloning and the Challenge of Regulation", The New England Journal of Medicine

NO: George J. Annas, from "Why We Should Ban Human Cloning", The New England Journal of Medicine

Attorney John A. Robertson contends there are many benefits to cloning and that a ban on privately funded cloning research is unjustified. Attorney and medical ethicist George J. Annas argues that cloning devalues people by depriving them of their uniqueness.

ISSUE 7. Should Genes for Human Diseases Be Patented?

YES: Glenn McGee, from "Gene Patents Can Be Ethical", Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics

NO: Jon F. Merz and Mildred K. Cho, from "Disease Genes Are Not Patentable: A Rebuttal of McGee", Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics

Bioethicist Glenn McGee argues that disease gene patents are not patents on products of nature but on scientific innovations. He asserts that correctly framed and issued disease-related gene patents will not preclude access to genetic material for educational and scientific uses. Bioethicists Jon F. Merz and Mildred K. Cho counter that disease genes are not patentable because they are indeed products of nature that exist independent of the ingenuity, innovation, and manufacture of humans.

ISSUE 8. Should There Be a Market in Body Parts?

YES: J. Radcliffe-Richards et al., from "The Case for Allowing Kidney Sales", The Lancet

NO: David J. Rothman, from "The International Organ Traffic", The New York Review of Books

Philosopher J. Radcliff-Richards and colleagues of the International Forum for Transplant Ethics contend that bans on selling organs remove the only hope of the destitute and the dying. Arguments against selling organs are weak attempts to justify the repugnance felt by people who are rich or healthy. Historian David J. Rothman asserts that trafficking in organs for transplantation is motivated by greed and subverts the ethical principles of the medical profession.

PART 3. Mind/Body Relationship

ISSUE 9. Is Stress Responsible for Disease?

YES: Editors of Harvard Health Letter, from "Can Stress Make You Sick?" Harvard Health Letter

NO: Christopher Caldwell, from "The Use and Abuse of Stress", The Weekly Standard

The editors of the Harvard Health Letter maintain that there is evidence that individuals who are chronically stressed possess an increased risk of cancer and heart disease. Writer Christopher Caldwell argues that no one, including doctors, can come to an agreement on what stress is, so stress can not be blamed as the cause of disease.

ISSUE 10. Can Spirituality Overcome Disease?

YES: Herbert Benson and Marg Stark, from Timeless Healing: The Power and Biology of Belief

NO: William B. Lindley, from "Prayer and Healing", Truth Seeker

Herbert Benson, an associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, and journalist Marg Stark contend that faith and spirituality will enhance and prolong life. William B. Lindley, associate editor of Truth Seeker, counters that there is no scientific way to determine that spirituality can heal.

PART 4. Sexuality and Gender Issues

ISSUE 11. Does Health Care Delivery and Research Benefit Men at the Expense of Women?

YES: Leslie Laurence and Beth Weinhouse, from Outrageous Practices: The Alarming Truth About How Medicine Mistreats Women

NO: Andrew G. Kadar, from "The Sex-Bias Myth in Medicine", The Atlantic Monthly

Health and medical reporters Leslie Laurence and Beth Weinhouse assert that women have been excluded from most research on new drugs and medical treatments. Physician Andrew G. Kadar argues that women actually receive more medical care and benefit more from medical research than men do.

ISSUE 12. Should Partial-Birth Abortion Be Banned?

YES: Robert J. White, from "Partial-Birth Abortion: A Neurosurgeon Speaks", America

NO: John M. Swomley, from "The `Partial-Birth' Debate in 1998", The Humanist

Professor and neurosurgeon Robert J. White states that Congress should completely ban late-term, partial-birth abortion. John M. Swomley, a professor emeritus of social ethics, maintains that the increased medical risk caused by banning late-term, partial-birth abortion is reason enough for Congress to allow the practice.

ISSUE 13. Will Most Postmenopausal Women Benefit From Estrogen Replacement Therapy?

YES: Michael Castleman, from "Hormonious Heart", Mother Jones

NO: Julie Felner, from "Dr. Susan Love Cuts Through the Hype on Women's Health", Ms.

Health columnist Michael Castleman asserts that unless a woman has a history of breast cancer, the benefits of postmenopausal hormone replacement therapy far outweigh the risks. Writer Julie Felner interviews physician Dr. Susan Love, who states that she is alarmed that many physicians prescribe hormone replacement therapy for all menopausal patients indefinitely.

PART 5. Public Health

ISSUE 14. Is Gun Control a Public Health Issue?

YES: Josh Sugarmann, from "Reverse Fire", Mother Jones

NO: Don B. Kates, Henry E. Schaffer, and William C. Waters IV, from "Public Health Pot Shots: How the CDC Succumbed to the Gun `Epidemic,'" Reason

Josh Sugarmann, executive director of the Violence Policy Center, argues that guns increase the costs of hospitalization, rehabilitation, and lost wages, making them a serious public health issue. Attorney Don B. Kates, professor of genetics Henry E. Schaffer, and William C. Waters IV, a physician, counter that most gun-related violence is caused by aberrants, not ordinary gun owners.

ISSUE 15. Should All Children Be Immunized Against Childhood Diseases?

YES: Arthur Allen, from "Injection Rejection", The New Republic

NO: Richard Moskowitz, from "Vaccination: A Sacrament of Modern Medicine", The Homoeopath

Freelance writer Arthur Allen states that parental refusal to immunize children could trigger disease outbreaks. Physician Richard Moskowitz argues that compulsory vaccination undermines the development of a healthy, functioning immune system.

ISSUE 16. Public Policy and Health: Is Global Warming a Real Threat?

YES: Ross Gelbspan, from "The Heat Is On", Harper's Magazine

NO: Arthur B. Robinson and Zachary W. Robinson, from "Science Has Spoken: Global Warming Is a Myth", The Wall Street Journal

Journalist Ross Gelbspan contends that we need to act now to prevent future catastrophic climatic changes that may result from global warming. Chemists Arthur B. Robinson and Zachary W. Robinson argue that even though carbon dioxide levels have increased during the past 20 years, global temperatures have decreased.

ISSUE 17. Should Cases of HIV Infection Be Reported by Name?

YES: Lawrence O. Gostin, from "Mandatory Name Reporting in HIV Cases? Yes", New York Law Journal

NO: Catherine Hanssens, from "Mandatory Name Reporting in HIV Cases? No", New York Law Journal

Law and public health professor Lawrence O. Gostin states that reporting cases of HIV infection by name is justified because the benefits to public health surveillance outweigh the risk of breaches of confidentiality from public health agencies. AIDS activist Catherine Hanssens asserts that the value of the information from named reporting of HIV infection will be limited if individuals at risk avoid HIV testing. Risks to privacy may occur from legislative action and from prosecutors seeking to criminalize HIV-related behavior.

ISSUE 18. Should Moderate Use of Alcohol Be Recommended?

YES: Dave Shiflett, from "Here's to Your Health", The American Spectator

NO: Meir J. Stampfer, Eric B. Rimm, and Diana Chapman Walsh, from "Alcohol, the Heart, and Public Policy", American Journal of Public Health

Writer Dave Shiflett contends that for years the antidrinking establishment has insisted that even moderate drinking is bad for health despite the fact that science indicates otherwise. Physicians Meir J. Stampfer and Eric B. Rimm and professor Diana Chapman Walsh argue that encouraging the use of alcohol, even in moderation, could lead to an increase in its consumption, with potentially dangerous results.

ISSUE 19. Is Marijuana Dangerous and Addictive?

YES: Eric A. Voth, from "Should Marijuana Be Legalized as a Medicine? No, It's Dangerous and Addictive", The World & I

NO: Ethan A. Nadelmann, from "Reefer Madness 1997: The New Bag of Scare Tactics", Rolling Stone

Eric A. Voth, medical director of Chemical Dependency Services at St. Francis Hospital in Topeka, Kansas, argues that marijuana produces many adverse effects and that its effectiveness as a medicine is supported only by anecdotes. Ethan A. Nadelmann, director of the Lindesmith Center, a New York drug policy research institute, asserts that government officials continue to promote the myth that marijuana is harmful and leads to the use of hard drugs.

PART 6. Consumer Health and Nutrition

ISSUE 20. Should a Low-Fat, High-Carbohydrate Diet Be Recommended for Everyone?

YES: William E. Connor and Sonja L. Connor, from "The Case for a Low-Fat, High-Carbohydrate Diet", The New England Journal of Medicine

NO: Martijn B. Katan, Scott M. Grundy, and Walter C. Willett, from "Beyond Low-Fat Diets", The New England Journal of Medicine

Physician William E. Connor and registered dietitian Sonja L. Connor argue that a low-fat, high-carbohydrate diet has many health benefits, including the reduction of disease risk factors. Nutritionist Martijn B. Katan and physicians Scott M. Grundy and Walter C. Willett maintain that a low-fat, high-carbohydrate diet does not reduce the risk of heart disease, cancer, or obesity.

ISSUE 21. Are Homeopathic Remedies Legitimate?

YES: Nancy Bruning, from "The Mysterious Power of Homeopathy", Natural Health

NO: Stephen Barrett, from "Homeopathy", Nutrition Forum

Author Nancy Bruning asserts that neither skeptics nor believers can exactly explain how homeopathy works but that it can successfully treat a wide range of health problems. Physician and health consumer advocate Stephen Barrett argues that homeopathic remedies are so dilute that they are useless.

Supplemental Materials

What is included with this book?

The New copy of this book will include any supplemental materials advertised. Please check the title of the book to determine if it should include any access cards, study guides, lab manuals, CDs, etc.

The Used, Rental and eBook copies of this book are not guaranteed to include any supplemental materials. Typically, only the book itself is included. This is true even if the title states it includes any access cards, study guides, lab manuals, CDs, etc.

Rewards Program