did-you-know? rent-now

Amazon no longer offers textbook rentals. We do!

did-you-know? rent-now

Amazon no longer offers textbook rentals. We do!

We're the #1 textbook rental company. Let us show you why.

9780073044019

Taking Sides: Clashing Views in Gender

by
  • ISBN13:

    9780073044019

  • ISBN10:

    0073044016

  • Edition: 3rd
  • Format: Paperback
  • Copyright: 2006-04-03
  • Publisher: McGraw-Hill/Dushkin
  • Purchase Benefits
  • Free Shipping Icon Free Shipping On Orders Over $35!
    Your order must be $35 or more to qualify for free economy shipping. Bulk sales, PO's, Marketplace items, eBooks and apparel do not qualify for this offer.
  • eCampus.com Logo Get Rewarded for Ordering Your Textbooks! Enroll Now
List Price: $35.31

Summary

This debate-style reader is designed to introduce students to controversies in gender studies. The readings, which represent the arguments of leading sociologists and social commentators, reflect a variety of viewpoints and have been selected for their liveliness and substance and because of their value in a debate framework. Taking Sides actively develops critical thinking skills by requiring students to analyze opposing viewpoints and reach considered judgements.

Table of Contents

PART 1. Definitions and Cultural Boundaries: A Moving Target

ISSUE 1. Is Anatomy Destiny?

YES: Anne Campbell, from “X and Y: It’s a Jungle Out There,” Psychology, Evolution, and Gender (August 2001)

NO: Richard Wilson, from “Puncturing the Genome Myth: Why the Genetic Code Fails to Explain Gendered Behaviour,” Psychology, Evolution, and Gender (December 2001)

Psychologist Anne Campbell argues that gene-level discoveries about the X and Y chromosomes give insight into differences between females and males. Richard Wilson suggests that environmental and social factors explain gendered behavior better than the genetic code.

ISSUE 2. Is Gender Identity Innate?

YES: David B. Cohen, from “Stranger in the Nest: Do Parents Really Shape Their Child’s Personality, Intelligence, or Character?” (Wiley & Sons, 1999)

NO: Bernice L. Hausman, from “Do Boys Have to Be Boys? Gender, Narrativity, and the John/Joan Case,” NWSA Journal (September 2000)

Clinical psychologist David B. Cohen examines the relatively more important role of genetic and other biological factors over parental influences on gender identity and discusses the John/Joan case as an example. Associate professor of English Bernice L. Hausman examines the narratives or stories told about the John/Joan case to reveal biases and oversights about nonbiological contributions to John/Joan’s experiences.

ISSUE 3. Is the Motive to Rape Biological?

YES: Randy Thornhill and Craig T. Palmer, from A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion (MIT Press, 2000)

NO: Mary P. Koss, from “Evolutionary Models of Why Men Rape: Acknowledging the Complexities,” Trauma, Violence, and Abuse (April 2000)

Randy Thornhill and Craig T. Palmer use evolutionary biology to explain the biological causes of rape. Clinical psychologist Mary P. Koss highlights the complexity of any causal analysis of rape and concludes that no theory emphasizing a single cause is adequate.

PART 2. Different Strokes: The Question of Difference

ISSUE 4. Do Women and Men Communicate Differently?

YES: Julia T. Wood, from Gendered Lives: Communication, Gender, and Culture (Wadsworth, 2001)

NO: Laura L. Winn and Donald L. Rubin, from “Enacting Gender Identity in Written Discourse: Responding to Gender Role Bidding in Personal Ads,” Journal of Language and Social Psychology (December 2001)

Julia T. Wood examines how gender images of masculinity and femininity result in different communication styles in women and men. Laura L. Winn and Donald L. Rubin report on a study that demonstrated that contextual factors were more important than biological sex in stylistic features of writing.

ISSUE 5. Do Women and Men Respond Differently to Stress?

YES: Shelley E. Taylor et al., from “Biobehavioral Repsonses to Stress in Females: Tend-and-Befriend, Not Flight-or-Fight,” Psychological Review (2000)

NO: John T. Cacioppo et al., from “Multilevel Integrative Analyses of Human Behavior: Social Neuroscience and the Complementing Nature of Social and Biological Approaches,” Psychological Bulletin (2000)

Social psychologist Shelley E. Taylor and her colleagues, in a review of the literature, conclude that there is an evolutionarily based biobehavioral mechanism that underlies women tend-and-befriend response to stress. Social psychologist John T. Cacioppo and his colleagues argue for the value of examining the influence of social influences on biological processes rather than vice versa. In numerous examples they document the effects of the context on fundamental biological processes.

ISSUE 6. Are Differences in Aggressive Behavior Between Women and Men Due to Gender-related Factors?

YES: Jacquelyn W. White, Patricia L.N. Donat, and Barrie Bondurant, from “A Developmental Examination of Violence Against Girls and Women,” in R. Unger, ed., Handbook of the Psychology of Women and Gender (John Wiley & Sons, 2001)

NO: Richard B. Felson, from Violence and Gender Reexamined (American Psychological Association, 2002)

Social psychologist Jacquelyn W. White and her colleagues conclude, based on a review of the literature, that girls and women are highly likely to be the targets of male aggression and are less likely to use physical aggression than men due to different developmental experiences. Social psychologist Richard B. Felson argues that aggression is related to physical strength and a general tendency toward violence, not male domination, and that there is not an epidemic of violence against women.

PART 3. From Ozzie to Harriet to My Two Dads: Gender in Childhood

ISSUE 7. Is Fetal Sex Selection Harmful to Society?

YES: Dena S. Davis, from Genetic Dilemmas: Reproductive Technology, Parental Choices, and Children’s Futures (Routledge, 2001)

NO: Rosamond Rhodes, from “Ethical Issues in Selecting Embryos,” Annals New York Academy of Sciences (2001)

Dena S. Davis argues that fetal sex selection is an ethical issue because it is really about gender selection that promotes traditional stereotypes and can interfere with a child’s right to an open future. Rosamond Rhodes describes the acceptable scope of fetal sex selection, as well as professional responsibilities of practitioners of reproductive medicine.

ISSUE 8. Are Fathers Essential for Children’s Well-Being?

YES: Sarah S. McLanahan and Marcia J. Carlson, from “Welform Reform, Fertility, and Father Involvement,” Future of Children (2002)

NO: Louise B. Silverstein and Carl F. Auerbach, from “Deconstructing the Essential Father,” American Psychologist (June 1999)

Sarah S. McLanahan and Marcia J. Carlson examine the negative effects of father-absence in children’s lives and offer suggestions for how to increase father involvement. Louise B. Silverstein and Carl F. Auerbach are the founders and co-directors of the Yeshiva Fatherhood Project. They conclude that neither mothers nor fathers are essential to children’s well-being; rather, children can thrive in a number of different family structures.

ISSUE 9. Should Same-Sex Couples Be Able to Marry?

YES: Lawrence A. Kurdek, from “Are Gay and Lesbian Cohabiting Couples Really Different from Heterosexual Married Couples?” Journal of Marriage and Family (November 2004)

NO: Peter Sprigg, from “Questions and Answers: What’s Wrong with Letting Same-Sex Couples ‘Marry’?” Family Research Council (2004)

Psychologist Lawrence A. Kurdek reports on a longitudinal study comparing gay and lesbian partners with partners from heterosexual married couples with children. For half of the comparisons there were no differences and for 78% of the comparisons for which differences were found, gay or lesbian partners functioned better than heterosexual partners. Peter Sprigg, director of the Center for Marriage and Family Studies at the Family Research Council, outlines why non-heterosexual relationships do not carry with them the same validity as heterosexual relationships, and therefore should not be allowed to marry legally. He states that the rights same-sex couples maintain that they would get by being able to marry are rights that are already available to them.

ISSUE 10. Can Lesbian and Gay Couples be Appropriate Parents for Children?

YES: American Psychological Association, from APA Policy Statement on Sexual Orientation, Parents, and Children (Adopted July 2004)

NO: Timothy J. Daily, from “State of the States: Update on Homosexual Adoption in the U.S.,” Family Research Council (2004)

The American Psychological Associations Council of Representatives adopted this resolution that was drafted by a task force of expert psychologists. The resolution, based on a thorough review of the literature, opposes any discrimination based on sexual orientation concludes that children reared by same-sex parents benefit from legal ties to each parent. Timothy J. Dailey, senior research fellow at the Center for Marriage and Family Studies, provides an overview of state laws that pertain to adoption by lesbian and gay parents. He points to studies showing that children do much better in family settings that include both a mother and a father, and that the sexual behaviors same-sex parents engage in make them, by definition, inappropriate role models for children.

PART 4. From 9 to 5: Gender in the World of Work

ISSUE 11. Do Sex Differences in Careers in Mathematics and Sciences Have a Biological Basis?

YES: Steve Pinker, from “The Science of Gender and Science: Pinker vs. Spelke, A Debate,” from Edge: The Third Culture (May 2005)

NO: Elizabeth Spelke, from “The Science of Gender and Science: Pinker vs. Spelke, A Debate” from Edge: The Third Culture (May 2005)

Steven Pinker reviews arguments supporting the claim that there is a biological basis for gender differences in math and science. Elizabeth Spelke argues that the under-representation of women in the sciences is due to environmental factors.

ISSUE 12. Is the Gender Wage Gap Justified?

YES: June O’Neill, from “The Gender Gap in Wages,” (American Economy Association May 2003)

NO: Hilary M. Lips, from “The Gender Pay Gap: Concrete Indicator of Women’s Progress Toward Equality,” (Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 2003)

June O’Neill suggests that the gender gap is largely due to nondiscriminatory factors, most notably those associated with women’s choices due to the division of labor in the home. Hilary M. Lips documents the continuing gender gap in wages and argues that a continuing undervaluing of women’s work due to stereotypes and prejudice maintains the wage gap.

ISSUE 13. Are Gender Inequalities Primarily Responsible for the Increased Number of Low-Wage Single-Mother Families?

YES: Sarah Drescher, from “Why Welfare Fails: Addressing the Pre-Existing Gender Inequalities Contributing to the Feminization of Poverty,” The Oregon Advocate (Summer 2000)

NO: Hilda Kahne, from “Low-Wage Single-Mother Families in This Jobless Recovery: Can Improved Social Policies Help?” Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy (2004)

Author Sarah Drescher contends that welfare reforms have inadequately addressed gender inequalities and have reinforced sex-segregated work and family roles, thereby worsening the "feminization of poverty." Hilda Kahne makes the argument that incomplete education and few training programs makes it more difficult for low-wage single mothers to raise their earnings.

PART 5. Gender and Sexuality: Double-Standards?

ISSUE 14. Is Female Circumcision Universally Wrong?

YES: Gerald Mackie, from “Female Genital Cutting: A Harmless Practice?” Medical Anthropology Quarterly (2003)

NO: Carla M. Obermeyer, from “The Health Consequences of Female Circumcision: Science, Advocacy, and Standards of Evidence,” Medical Anthropology Quarterly (2003)

Gerald Mackie takes a scientific approach to challenge the argument that female genital cutting is not always harmful, citing multiple examples of physical and psychological harm. Carla M. Obermeyer argues that a lack of research precludes us from fully understanding female circumcision and claiming that it is responsible for a variety of harmful health outcomes. She includes examples of no harm.

ISSUE 15. Should "Abstinence-Until-Marriage" Be the Only Message for Teens?

YES: Bridget E. Maher, from “Abstinence Until Marriage: The Best Message for Teens,” Family Research Council (2004)

NO: Debra Hauser, from Five Years of Abstinence-Only-Until-Marriage Education: Assessing the Impact (2004)

Bridget E. Maher argues that far too much funding has gone into programs that teach young people about sexuality and contraception—programs that she concludes are ineffective. Debra Hauser, in an evaluation of numerous abstinence-only-until-marriage programs that received funding under the Title V Social Security Act, concludes that they show few short-term benefits and no lasting, positive effects; rather such programs may actually worsen sexual health outcomes.

ISSUE 16. Can Women’s Sexuality Be Free From Traditional Gender Constraints?

YES: Elizabeth Sheff, from “Polyamorous Women, Sexual Subjectivity and Power,” Journal of Contemporary Ethnography (June 2005)

NO: Cheryl B. Travis, Kayce L. McGinnnis, and Kristin M. Bardari, from “Beauty, Sexuality, and Identity: The Social Control of Women,” Sexuality, Society, and Feminism: Psychological Perspectives on Women (2000)

Elizabeth Shef conducted an ethnographic study that suggests that engaging in nontraditional relationships can help women reject sexual objectification and enlarge their sexual subjectivity. Cheryl B. Travis and her colleagues argue that society’s social construction of beauty has so deeply affected the socialization of girls that it plays a key role in controlling women’s sexuality. Their analysis of the impact of the beauty myth calls into question whether any woman can truly have a sexual self that has not been shaped by societal ideals.

ISSUE 17. Are Adult-Child Sexual Relations Always Harmful?

YES: Sonja Grover, from “On Power Differentials and Children’s Rights: A Dissonance Interpretation of the Rind and Associates, Study on Child Sexual Abuse,” Ethical Human Sciences and Services (Spring 2003)

NO: Bruce Rind, from “An Empirical Examination of Sexual Relations Between Adolescents and Adults,” Journal of Psychology and Human Sexuality (2004)

Sonja Grover argues that any sexual contact with a minor by an adult under any circumstances violates the human rights of a child. Bruce Rind suggests that it is important to distinguish adult-child from adult-adolescent sexual relationships, suggesting that the latter may not be harmful because adolescents are likely to interpret the relationship differently than children.

PART 6. Girl Interrupted: Gender and Mental Health

ISSUE 18. Is Premenstrual Syndrome a Hormonally Based Disorder?

YES: Torbjörn Bäckström et al., from “The Role of Hormones and Hormonal Treatments in Premenstrual Syndrome,” CNS Drugs (2003)

NO: Joan C. Chrisler, from “PMS as a Culture-Bound Syndrome,” In J.C. Chrisler, C. Golden, and P.D. Rozee eds., Lectures on the Psychology of Women (The McGraw-Hill Companies, 2004)

Torbjörn Bäckström describe the relationship between hormones and premenstrual syndrome, also discussing the effects on the brain and various treatment options. Joan C. Chrisler argues that PMS is a culturally constructed disorder whose symptoms are tied to cultural meanings and social norms. PMS, as understood in U.S. women, does not manifest itself the same in all cultures.

ISSUE 19. Is Reparative Therapy Effective in Changing One’s Sexual Orientation?

YES: Robert L. Spitzer, from “Can Some Gay Men and Lesbians Change Their Sexual Orientation? 200 Participants Reporting a Change From Homosexual to Heterosexual Orientation,” Archives of Sexual Behavior (October 2003)

NO: Helena M. Carlson, from “A Methodological Critique of Spitzer’s Research on Reparative Therapy” and Lisa M. Diamond, “Reconsidering ‘Sexual Desire’ in the Context of Reparative Therapy,” Archives of Sexual Behavior (October 2003)

Robert L. Spitzer reports on a study that identified a subgroup of gay men and lesbians who reported at least some minimal change in some aspect of their sexual orientation. Helena M Carlson and Lisa M. Diamond, in separate critiques, note numerous flaws in Spitzer’s methods and conceptualization of sexual desire. Both conclude that his conclusions are flawed.

ISSUE 20. Is Transgenderism a Psychological Disorder?

YES: American Psychiatric Association, from “Gender Identity Disorder,” Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (2000)

NO: Carla Golden, from “The Intersexed and the Transgendered: Rethinking Sex/Gender,” In J.C. Chrlisler, C. Golden, & P.D. Rozee, eds., Lectures on the Psychology of Women (The McGraw-Hill Companies, 2004)

The DSM-IV, the official manual of the American Psychiatric Association, presents the diagnostic criteria that must be met in order for a person to be diagnosed with a gender identity disorder. Carla Golden argues that the diagnosis of gender identity disorder is problematic. It is the socially constructed nature of sex and gender that has problematized some forms of gender expression while privileging others.

Supplemental Materials

What is included with this book?

The New copy of this book will include any supplemental materials advertised. Please check the title of the book to determine if it should include any access cards, study guides, lab manuals, CDs, etc.

The Used, Rental and eBook copies of this book are not guaranteed to include any supplemental materials. Typically, only the book itself is included. This is true even if the title states it includes any access cards, study guides, lab manuals, CDs, etc.

Rewards Program