Weber and Toennies: Comparative Sociology in Historical Perspective

by Maier,Joseph B.

• ISBN13: 9781560001348
• ISBN10: 1560001348
• Format: Hardcover
• Copyright: 1994-04-30
• Publisher: Routledge

Summary

This collection of selected essays by Werner J. Cahnman brings together out of scattered dispersion his writings about Max Weber, Ferdinand Toennies, and historical sociology. The great theoretical range and depth of his intellect and mastery of sociological thinking is apparent as he discusses the impact of romanticism on modern thought, and how Weber and Toennies both analyzed and reacted to modernity. Cahnman places Weber (1864-1920), the dominant figure in twentieth-century sociology, in the midst of the methodological controversies so characteristic of contemporary social science, and he fully discusses the overarching importance of Weberian ideal-type theory. Although less well-known than Weber, Toennies (1855-1936) was also a sociologist of the first rank. He is best remembered for his enormously influential twin concepts, Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft, which contributed to our understanding of the historical and sociological basis for the change from premodern to modern societies. The essays in this volume establish Toennies' intellectual connections to Karl Marx, Max Weber, Emile Durkheim, and Herbert Spencer, and clarify his influence upon American sociology. Cahnman stood against strict separations between history and sociology, and his essays are all informed by a wonderful admixture of the theoretical and the concrete. They demonstrate how a genuine historical sociology, not unlike that of Weber and Toennies, can find and explain linkages between seemingly disparate events spanning time and place. This volume will be of interest to sociologists, political scientists, and intellectual historians. Werner J. Cahnman (1920-1980) studied at the Universities of Munich, Berlin, and Chicago, and taught at many American universities including Rutgers and the New Schiool for Social Research. Joseph B. Maier is professor emeritus of sociology, Rutgers University, and chairman of the interdisciplinary University Seminar on Contents and Methods of the Social Sciences at Columbia University. Judith Marcus is on the faculty of Kenyon College, and the author of Georg Lukacs and Thomas Mann: A Study in the Sociology of Literature. Zoltan Tarr has taught sociology and history at City College of CUNY, the Graduate Faculty, New School for Social Research, and at Rutgers University. He is the author of The Frankfurt School.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
Introduction	p. 1
Perspectives on Max Weber
Max Weber and the Methodological Controversy in the Social Sciences	p. 23
Ideal-Type Theory: Max Weber's Concept and Some of Its Derivations	p. 49
Notes on The Sociology of Religion by Max Weber	p. 61
A Review: Mitzman's Iron Cage	p. 67
Comparative Approach to Toennies
Toennies and Marx: Evaluation	p. 73
Toennies and Spencer: Evaluation	p. 77
Toennies and Weber: Comparison	p. 81
Toennies and Durkheim	p. 87
Toennies and Social Change	p. 89
Toennies, Durkheim, and Weber	p. 109
Toennies in America	p. 125
A Research Note on Phenomenology and Symbolic Interactionism	p. 147
Essays in Historical Sociology: Pure, Applied, and Empirical
Historical Sociology: What It Is and What It Is Not	p. 157
Vico and Historical Sociology	p. 171
Starting Points in Sociology: Hobbes, Toennies, Vico	p. 179
The Historical Sociology of Cities: A Critical Review	p. 201
How Cities Grew...	p. 211
The Significance of Urban History	p. 211
The Historical Typology of Cities	p. 219
Social Stratification in Cities	p. 226
The Location and Ecology of Cities	p. 233
The Rise of Civilization as a Paradigm of Social Change	p. 241
Religion, Race, and Ethnicity
Religion and Nationality	p. 265
Adolph Fischhof and the Problem of the Reconciliation of Nationalities	p. 275
Nature and Varieties of Ethnicity	p. 289
The Mediterranean and Caribbean Regions: A Comparison in Race and Culture Contacts	p. 309
Appendix: Rudolf Hess; or, An Introduction to the Emergence of German Geopolitics	p. 319
Index	p. 337
Table of Contents provided by Blackwell. All Rights Reserved.