Witches of the Atlantic World : An Historical Reader and Primary Sourcebook

by Breslaw, Elaine G.

• ISBN13: 9780814798515
• ISBN10: 0814798519
• Format: Paperback
• Copyright: 2000-08-01
• Publisher: Ingram Pub Services

Summary

This unique anthology is the first to provide a multicultural perspective on witchcraft from the 15th to 18th century. Featuring primary documents as well as scholarly interpretations, Witches of the Atlantic Worldbuilds upon information regarding both Christian and non-Christian beliefs about possession and the demonic. Elaine G. Breslaw draws on Native American, African, South American, and African-American sources, as well as the European and New England heritage, to illuminate the ways in which witchcraft in early America was an attempt to understand and control evil and misfortune in the New World.Organized into sections on folklore and magic, diabolical possession, Christian perspectives, and the question of gender, the volume includes selections by Cotton Mather, Matthew Hopkins, and Samuel Willard, among others; Salem trial testimonies; and commentary by a host of distinguished scholars.Together the materials demonstrate how the Protestant and Catholic traditions shaped American concepts, and how multicultural aspects played a key role in the Salem experience.Witches of the Atlantic Worldsheds new light on one of the most perplexing aspects of American history and provides important background for the continued scholarly and popular interest in witches and witchcraft today.

Table of Contents

Preface and Acknowledgments	xiii
Introduction	1	(12)
I. Christian Perspectives on Witchcraft in Europe and North America	13	(84)
Primary Sources
The Methods of the Devil	21	(7)
Heinrich Kramer
Jacob Sprenger
On Witchraft	28	(9)
Reginald Scot
The Discovery of Witches: In Answer to Several Queries	37	(5)
Matthew Hopkins
On Witches and Witchraft	42	(7)
Cotton Mather
Commentaries
The Non-Existent Society of Witches	49	(11)
Norman Cohn
The Relevance of Social Anthropology to the Historical Study of English Witchcraft	60	(12)
Keith Thomas
Scottish Witchcraft in Its Comparative Setting	72	(5)
Christina Larner
Witchraft and Puritan Beliefs	77	(12)
Richard Weisman
A World of Wonders	89	(8)
David Hall
II. Non-Christian Beliefs	97	(132)
A. Europeans and North American Colonists
The Night Battles	107	(10)
Carlo Ginzburg
The Night-Witch in Popular Imagination	117	(9)
Norman Cohn
Image Magic and the Like	126	(6)
George Lyman Kittredge
Divining, Healing, and Destroying	132	(13)
Richard Godbeer
B. Africans
Activities of African Witches	145	(8)
Geoffrey Parrinder
Witchcraft among the Azande	153	(16)
E. E. Evans-Pritchard
C. African Americans
Magical Practices and Beliefs	169	(7)
Philip D. Morgan
Archaeological Evidence for a Possible Witch in Barbados, West Indies	176	(5)
Jerome Handler
An Afro-American Folk Religion	181	(8)
William D. Piersen
D. American Indians
The Indian Response	189	(7)
Fernando Cervantes
Indian Shamans and English Witches	196	(8)
Alfred Cave
Pueblo Witchraft	204	(9)
Marc Simmons
The Medicine Man and the Kanaima	213	(8)
Walter E. Roth
Factions and Exclusions in Two South American Village Systems	221	(8)
Peter Riviere
III. Diabolical Possession	229	(54)
Primary Sources
The Possession of Elizabeth Knapp of Groton	235	(11)
Samuel Willard
Bewitchment of the Goodwin Children	246	(13)
Cotton Mather
Commentaries
Classic Accusers: The Possessed	259	(8)
Joseph Klaits
Possession and Dispossession	267	(5)
Keith Thomas
Witchcraft in New England	272	(5)
Chadwick Hansen
Witchcraft: The ``Captivity to Spectres''	277	(6)
Richard Slotkin
IV. Gender	283	(72)
Primary Sources
Why Women Are Chiefly Addicted to Evil Superstitions	289	(7)
Heinrich Kramer
Jacob Sprenger
The Character of a Virtuous Woman	296	(4)
Cotton Mather
Two Sermons on Women and the Devil	300	(5)
Samuel Willard
Commentaries
The Making of the Great Witch-Hunt	305	(4)
Norman Cohn
The Myth of the Improved Status of Protestant Women: The Case of the Witchcraze	309	(13)
Allison P. Coudert
The Devil, the Body, and the Feminnine Soul in Puritan New England	322	(8)
Elizabeth Reis
Words, Witches, and Woman Trouble	330	(7)
Jane Kamensky
The Economic Basis of Witchcraft	337	(10)
Carol F. Karlsen
Who Were the Witches?	347	(8)
Christina Larner
V. Salem: A Case Study of the Primary Documents	355	(72)
A. Legal Procedures
Conjuration and Witches	365	(4)
Michael Dalton
On the Identification of a Witch	369	(8)
William Perkins
B. The Accused
Examination of Tituba	377	(4)
Examination of Rebecca Nurse	381	(4)
Examination of Bridget Bishop	385	(4)
Narrative of the Salem Events	389	(10)
Deodat Lawson
C. The Accusers
Elizabeth Hubbard against Tituba	399	(1)
Abigail Williams against Tituba and Rebecca Nurse	400	(2)
Ann Putnam, Jr., against Rebecca Nurse	402	(1)
Deliverance Hobbs against Bridget Bishop	403	(2)
John Hale against Bridget Bishop	405	(2)
Advice of the Clergy	407	(4)
D. The Doubters
A Multitude of Errors	411	(9)
Thomas Brattle
The Apology of the Jury	420	(2)
That Sad Catastrophe	422	(5)
John Hale
VI. Historians' Commentaries on the Salem Case	427	(38)
Witchcraft at Salem Village	430	(7)
Charles Upham
Witchcraft, the Courts, and Countermagic	437	(7)
Richard Godbeer
Tituba's Confession: The Multicultural Dimensions of the 1692 Salem Witch-Hunt	444	(10)
Elaine G. Breslaw
Through the Clouds	454	(11)
Larry Gragg
VII. Medical and Psychological Interpretations	465	(24)
Ergot and the Salem Witchraft Affair	467	(5)
Mary K. Matossian
Ergot, Demonic Possession, and Hallucinogenic Drugs	472	(8)
H. Sidky
Underlying Themes in the Witchcraft of Seventeenth-Century New England	480	(9)
John Demos
VIII. The Salem Legacy	489	(36)
Primary Source
An Act against Conjuration, Witchcraft and Dealing with Evil and Wicked Spirits	495	(4)
Commentaries
Altered Lives	499	(8)
Elaine G. Breslaw
1692: Some New Perspectives	507	(5)
Paul Boyer
Stephen Nissenbaum
The Invisible World at the Vanishing Point	512	(4)
Richard Weisman
Magic, Astrology, and the Early American Religious Heritage, 1600--1760	516	(9)
Jon Butler
Afterword	525	(2)
Bibliographic Note	527	(6)
Subject Index	533	(9)
Name Index	542	(8)
About the Editor	550

Excerpts

Chapter One

Christian Perspectives on Witchcraft in

Europe and North America

RELIGIOUS CREEDS AND WITCHCRAFT practices are both aspects of supernatural belief--their focus is the spiritual realm. From the Christian perspective, however, witchcraft is in opposition to religion and is linked to demonic practices. The four primary sources excerpted in part 1, written between 1486 and 1689, illustrate the variety of notions prevalent among the educated Christian population about the working of witches and the devil in Europe, England, and England's Puritan colonies.

    The first selection, from the Malleus Maleficarum (also known as the "Hammer of Witches"), was compiled by two Dominican priests and inquisitors in Germany in the fifteenth century, the Inquisitor General Father Jacob Sprenger and Father Heinrich Krämer, called by his Latinized name, Institoris, who was the main author. The work became the most important source of information on witches and witchcraft for both Protestants and Catholics and was consulted by theologians as late as the eighteenth century. Their compilation of witch stories provides both a theoretical support for the idea of an evil witch and a practical manual for identifying diabolical supporters. Much of what they report in this excerpt was part of the occult folklore of medieval and pre-Christian Europe. But a great deal of the elaboration, extracted under torture, came from the fantasies, both sexual and diabolical, suggested by the inquisitors themselves.

    Krämer, who was the major instigator of witch persecutions in Germany, was particularly anxious to prove the guilt of those he tortured and to place their crimes within the theological context of a devil's pact and conspiracy. Sprenger later regretted his approval of Krämer's excessive methods.

    The stereotype of the witch, according to the Malleus , was one who, through an agreement with the devil, acquired special powers to both do harm and solve problems or cure sickness. Unlike European folk beliefs regarding occult practices, the Catholic inquisitors and later the Protestant witch finders made no distinction between helpful witchcraft and the intent to do harm. All witchcraft, they assumed, derived from the devil and was therefore inherently evil or at least anti-Christian. The Catholic inquisitors inspired a new conspiratorial mythology about witches as people who made a solemn agreement to serve the devil by participating in a variety of antisocial acts (such as sexual orgies among themselves and with Satan), promoting the murder of infants, committing acts of cannibalism, and seducing more followers. All this, they argued, was with the intention of subverting Christianity. Their theories about the demonic focus of magical practices lingers on in the mythology of witchcraft today.

    Matthew Hopkins, a Protestant, was England's most active witch hater in the seventeenth century. Under the influence of the Malleus , he set out to prove that witches in league with the devil were rampant in parts of eastern England in the 1640s. Hopkins established himself as a "witch finder," testified against those of questionable reputation, forced confessions using forms of torture slightly more subtle than the Continental rack, and inflicted countermagic on his victims such as the water test, which had been rejected by English theologians and most jurists. In his 1647 pamphlet excerpted here, Hopkins defended himself against charges of personally benefiting from these actions. He also claimed that his methods had ferreted out and brought on the death of two hundred people. At the same time Hopkins had added new elements to the lore surrounding witches by giving the devil's helpers a variety of ludicrous new names and bodily shapes.

    Not all English thinkers took the folklore about witches seriously. Reginald Scot, a learned Protestant layman and country gentleman with scientific interests, was moved by what he thought was an unwarranted persecution of old women to write his Discoverie of Witchcraft (1584). He thought that many of those confessing to witchcraft suffered from some psychic disorder. In arguing against the witch trials he was highly critical of the demonologists such as the authors of the Malleus .

    In dissecting demonological lore as an illusion and witchcraft stories as delusions, Scot also suggests what has been affirmed by modern scholars about the origin of the accusations. A quarrel between a poor old woman and her potential benefactor could result in harsh words that, when followed by some accident or illness in the benefactor's family, led him or her to blame the old woman for causing the problem through her witchcraft. Charges made against such helpless and possibly senile old women often led to confessions that were partly the result of the power of suggestion. Scot acknowledges that a confession could give such women a feeling of control. They reasoned, he thought, that if they were accused of such power over others, maybe it was true. He also observes that some of the confessions were due to the effects of "melancholy," an old term for depression, leading to delusions.

    In a typically Protestant mode, Scot attributes the witchcraft lore to the work of learned Catholic writers and absolves the Protestant thinkers. His refutation of witchcraft beliefs is in part an attack on Catholic sacraments. He was offended by the continued acceptance of older magical religious rites even by those professing to be Protestants. Scot's arguments became a model for later writers who continued to link witchcraft only with Catholicism and attempted to disassociate their own belief system from the demonized magic of witchcraft.

    In America, where few people were persecuted for witchcraft before the 1660s, belief in magical powers was still part of the mental baggage the Puritans brought from old England. Those English folk beliefs regarding witchcraft were reinforced by zealous Puritan reformers concerned about the decline in religious fervor after the early years of settlement. The excerpt from Cotton Mather's 1689 Memorable Providences " details what he thought was evidence of the devil's work in the covenanted Puritan community. He associates religious backsliders with diabolical acts. He does not call for any mass executions of suspected witches; rather, he calls for a spiritual renewal to prevent the spread of their activities. In the process he provides a concise outline of his beliefs about witches, their powers, and why they appeared in Massachusetts.

    Mather accepts the notion of a diabolical pact and the idea that God permits evil spirits to roam as a warning. Satan's presence was to test the faith of men. The appearance of witches and their use of witchcraft in the Puritan community, therefore, implied a decline in religious conviction--a loss of faith among God's chosen. By publishing this evidence of a diabolical presence, Mather hoped to reform the less zealous and offer them the possibility of redemption through prayer and confession. His stories, though, may well have contributed to popular fears by confirming folktales of such miraculous happenings and paving the way for the more vigorous prosecution of witches in New England.

    Faced with these examples from the learned community and a host of other commentaries both lay and clerical on the witchcraft infection, twentieth-century scholars have concluded that most of the theological arguments were based on myth and fantasy and an understandable misconstruction of the causes of natural disasters. The following selections from five scholars on Continental, English, Scottish, and American theological beliefs about witchcraft explore the mental world that predisposed people to accept such ideas as fact. The authors all point out the close connections between the religious environment and witchcraft beliefs. The selections analyze the origins of the stereotype of the witch and the theological notions that prevailed at the time.

    Norman Cohn dismantles the notion, propounded by Margaret Murray and others, that the European witch hunt from the fifteenth to the seventeenth centuries was aimed at a society of witches that actually existed, adherents of a highly organized pre-Christian religion that was practiced throughout Europe and had descended from ancient fertility cults. Cohn does not dispute the persistence of pre-Christian beliefs or practices; rather, his point is that there is simply no historical evidence for the existence of an organized body of witches as posited by the witch hunters. Claims that witches practiced infanticide, kissed the behind of a toad or a goat, or participated in a secret conspiratorial society of witches were pure fiction, Cohn maintains. These stereotypes belong in the realm of literary creations or possibly drug-induced hallucinations.

    Keith Thomas, less concerned with the truth or falsehood of particular witchcraft lore, explores the intersection of religion with ideas about evil and magic in both popular and elite thinking. In England, where the idea of devil worship seems to have been peripheral to most accusations of witchcraft, the crucial factor in any witch scare was the preoccupation with maleficium , the doing of harm. But not all harmful events or natural disasters were attributed to witchcraft. Drawing on anthropological theory, Thomas argues that witchcraft is chosen as a satisfactory explanation when it is possible to take action against some likely scapegoat. The identification of such a witch happens as a result of interpersonal tension or grudges motivating an act of vengeance. In England, witch and accuser, he discovered, always knew each other and had a history of prior conflict.

    Moreover, witch beliefs served a variety of social functions. They may have provided some sense of control over the gravest misfortune while also helping to maintain communal harmony. Thomas suggests that accusations of witchcraft were a means of restraining deviant people, usually the poor with unacceptable social characteristics. On the other hand, the threat by these dependent members of the society to use evil magic gave the poor themselves some control over their own lives--a means of retaliation against those who would deny them some benefit. Their curses offered the same protective effect against oppression as the courts gave to the wealthy. Accusations of witchcraft had as much to do with social problems and social structure as they did with supernatural concerns and theological justifications.

    Building on the work of both Cohn and Thomas, Christina Larner takes as a given that most of the early modern witchcraft beliefs were amalgamations of more ancient lore elaborated by the elite for their own political or theological purposes. She compares the witch hunts in Scotland, which reached the ferocious intensity of those in Germany, with the milder events in England in the seventeenth century. Although Scotland's witch hunters added little to theories about witchcraft, she notes that because of the unusual political structure in that country, the pattern of accusations and beliefs differed from those in England and on the Continent while borrowing from both. As on the Continent, Larner points out, the competitive spirit of the local clergy in league with civil authorities often fueled witch panics. As in England, the fantasies of the witches' coven had few horrific details, and charges of sexual orgies or acts of cannibalism were rare.

    In Scotland as everywhere else there was no single continuous witch hunt but rather sporadic occurrences between 1590 and 1662 and thereafter a decline. King James VI of Scotland (soon to become James I of England), convinced that demons were infesting the land, certainly encouraged the earliest outbreaks. Then a second wave coincided with the peak of Continental trials during the 1620s. But the most sustained period occurred between 1649 and 1661, an era of reforming Presbyterianism in Scotland and Puritan ascendancy in England, finally ending soon after the restoration of the Anglican monarchy in the 1660s. These were times of acute tension between church and state, reflecting a determination on the part of the reforming ministry to secure legitimacy and maintain control.

    What is even more significant, Larner notes, the Protestant stress on the personal relationship with the devil and the idea of a covenant, a people's pact with God, so central to the Calvinist idea, gave the concept of a diabolical pact a peculiar intensity. That Calvinist emphasis would be echoed across the Atlantic in the Puritan villages of New England.

    The American version of radical Protestantism in New England certainly encouraged fantasies of diabolical action. Richard Weisman focuses on the specific relationship between Puritan doctrines and witchcraft beliefs in New England. The intellectual dilemma faced by the theologians was to reconcile a variety of paradoxical beliefs--God was sovereign, yet there existed a powerful devil; the God-given social order was immutable, yet arbitrary events could occur; God had a divine, providential plan for humans, yet occult practices violated God's law. The concept of a diabolical pact resolved these dilemmas, giving Puritans both a scapegoat for their own religious decline and a temporarily satisfying way out of their theological paradoxes. Thus the strengthened belief in witchcraft may have been an essential element of the peculiar Puritanism developing in America.

    In the broader intellectual context, Europeans of the time, whether Puritans or not, like their Indian and African counterparts discussed in part 2, lived in a world of supernatural forces that could trip them up and cause calamities for unknown reasons. David Hall evokes the mentality of that seventeenth-century world, both folk and elite, that saw all natural events as the work of invisible forces. Theological language and the printing industry might have helped shape the thinking about those wonders, but it did not stop the tendency to see prodigies and evil omens in everyday events or a general belief in the efficacy of magical rituals to resolve problems. While the printing industry inspired even greater interest in supernatural lore among the folk, the clergy tried to shift attention to the wonder workings of God rather than demons and witches. The failure of the ministry to overcome the attraction of both folklore and zealous publishers suggests another reason for the continuing focus on witches and witchcraft among the lay population. The English, of course, were not unique in these beliefs.

    The source of those wonders and portents in the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century world may have differed among different classes and cultures, but ordinary people assumed that the world was a mysterious place full of miraculous occurrences. Almost everyone everywhere in the Atlantic world of the time, the literate and the illiterate, the highly placed elite and the common people, imagined that remote and unseen forces guided their destinies and caused their misfortunes. How satisfying it must have been to give a face and name to the cause of such unhappiness, to find a witch.

Copyright © 2000 New York University. All rights reserved.